How much pain are they willing or can they afford to take? The answer: Virtually none. The economy is not the stock market, but the stock market is the economy. Or rather the stock market is the biggest threat to the economy and must be protected at all costs.
To me it was never a question that the Fed was going to cut rates again in 2020 despite claims of the 3 rates cuts in 2019 cuts just having been a “mid-cycle adjustment”, or despite claims of a coming reflation trade or despite new market highs exceeding all expectations thanks to the Fed liquidity.
No, I said it right at the beginning of January:
Sven Henrich✔@NorthmanTrader
The Fed will cut rates again in 2020.
And the question to me, despite all the brave Fed claims, was simply how much market pain they’d be willing to endure before shifting the brave stance again. Just last week I posed:
Sven Henrich✔@NorthmanTrader
Prediction: If markets drop 10%+ before April the Fed will not end repo or its treasury bills buying program as indicated.
If anything they will increase it and cut rates.Why? Because markets will demand it & this Fed has no backbone whatsoever & his beholden to markets.
Sven Henrich✔@NorthmanTrader
Ah who am I kidding… they’ll freak at 5% down
In 2019 Powell stepped in with jawboning at every 5%-7% down.
And 3 days later and 5% down here comes the jawboning. RATE CUTS NOW!!!
No, I’m not kidding, here’s the jawbone via former president of the Minneapolis Fed:
The Fed Needs to Cut Rates Now:
“The Fed’s rate-setting Federal Open Market Committee holds its next meeting on March 17-18. I don’t think that the FOMC should wait that long to deal with this clear and pressing danger. I would urge an immediate cut of at least 25 basis points and arguably 50 basis points.”
Panic, pre-emptive cutting.
And of course a Fed, that simply can’t afford to disappoint markets for fear of any sell-off is now faced with a market that is now pricing in 2 rate cuts in 2020.
But it’s not just the Fed that is now again under pressure to deliver.
3 down days and 5% down and the political jawboning is already in full swing:
Donald J. Trump✔@realDonaldTrump
The Coronavirus is very much under control in the USA. We are in contact with everyone and all relevant countries. CDC & World Health have been working hard and very smart. Stock Market starting to look very good to me!
Robert Costa✔@costareports
News: Kudlow spoke w/ Post after markets closed. Encouraged people to buy.
“The coronavirus will not last forever. The US looks well-contained and the economy is fundamentally sound,” he told me. “If you’re a long term investor, you should seriously consider buying these dips.”
How much value to put in these efforts? The political calculus is clear: Keep markets elevated for the election:
Kyle Griffin✔@kylegriffin1
WaPo last week: Trump has told advisers that he does not want the administration to do or say anything regarding the Coronavirus outbreak that would further spook the markets. He remains worried that any large-scale outbreak could hurt his reelection bid. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trumps-soft-touch-with-chinas-xi-worries-advisers-who-say-more-is-needed-to-combat-coronavirus-outbreak/2020/02/16/93de385a-5019-11ea-9b5c-eac5b16dafaa_story.html#click=https://t.co/UYEO6HYb4i …
Trump’s soft touch with China’s Xi worries advisers who say more is needed to combat coronavirus…
The president has said repeatedly that pushing for a harder line against China could backfire because President Xi Jinping controls the government “totally” and will not work with the United States…
washingtonpost.com
Whatever it takes. Does it have economic predictive meaning? Not necessarily:
Sven Henrich✔@NorthmanTrader
Kudlow 101: There Ain’t No Recession
“Yesterday’s tremendous ADP jobs report puts the dagger into the very heart of the recession case.” – Larry Kudlow December 6, 2007*Recession started December 2007https://www.nationalreview.com/kudlows-money-politics/kudlow-101-there-aint-no-recession-larry-kudlow/ …
Kudlow 101: There Ain’t No Recession
Yesterday’s tremendous ADP jobs report puts the dagger into the very heart of the recession case. The fact is, America is working. Look at how close the reports parallel one another. So here’s my p…
nationalreview.com
They will jawbone until the bulls come home. Fact is the virus is still not contained and if a global recession unfolds they can cut rates and jawbone until they’re blue in the face.
It remains all about control.
But the very effort itself reveals something: They are worried about losing control of markets for a sizable downturn in markets may trigger what they are trying to avoid for obvious reasons: A recession. And the threshold of accepting any sort of pain in markets is thin: 5% and you see them react.
The question remains about efficacy. We’ve just seen an attempt to put a floor under the market. Let’s see if it lasts. Calls for rate cuts now after 5% down, that’s now the benchmark. Comes to show how fragile this market construct really is. It can’t hold its own without Momma Fed.
