The NAR reported a decline in the number of contracts to purchase existing homes in August, with a seasonally adjusted decline of 1.6%. That was better than economists’ consensus expectations of -2.3%. Fooled again! Too pessimistic again. Economists don’t seem to be able to get a handle on the nature of housing bubbles.
If you have been reading these pages for any amount of time, you recognize that the seasonally adjusted headline number may or may not represent reality. It isn’t the actual number, and depending on the seasonal adjustment factor, the headlines are all too often misleading.
The actual number of contracts fell 1.3% in August on a month to month basis, which is roughly equivalent to 1,500 units. Since this is an unadjusted number, in order to judge whether this represents strength or weakness we must compare it with past Augusts. The average change for August over the prior 10 years was an increase of 1.2%. This August was weaker than average and much weaker than the August 2012 gain of +4.1%.
Whether this was a result of weaker demand due to higher rates or the fact that many buyers were stymied by tighter than ever inventories is debatable. In fact, contracts were up 2.9% over August 2012 when mortgage rates were far lower than they were this August. We could reasonably conclude from that that higher rates have not materially suppressed demand, and that tight inventories are playing a role in suppressing sales. In my 40 years in or analyzing the housing business, I have noted that rising rates have always stimulated demand until they became so high as to make prices unaffordable.
The only time I saw that dynamic was in 1981-92. For the most part, rising rates have stoked an inflationary psychology in housing, motivating people to buy now to beat both rising prices and rising interest rates. That psychology is certainly at work now with prices rising nationally on average at the rate of 16-18% annually.
Tight inventories continue to impact the market, driving the price bubble and possibly restricting the number of sales. With demand still in an uptrend, a larger increase in inventories would be required to put a lid on the price gains.
The inventory to contracts ratio stood at 4.85 in August, up only slightly from 4.77 in July, and up a bit more versus the seasonal low of 3.95 in March. This is a 7 year record low for the month of August, down from 5.32 in August 2012 and a peak of 10.28 in August 2007. While a normal seasonal rise in this ratio is under way, the downtrend has not yet reversed. Prices are likely to continue rising until the trend of this ratio turns materially higher.
Earlier I reported that Housing Recovery Is An Illusion While Housing Inflation Rages. Current data from several other sources contradicts the idea promoted by the mainstream media that the housing bubble is slowing due to the rise in mortgage rates. The risk of an approaching Housing Crash II is still growing as house prices gain at the rate of 16-18% per year nationally, and far faster in the hottest bubble markets.
Want to learn more about my approach to the markets? Enjoy the short videos in the right sidebar!
Stay up to date with the machinations of the Fed, Treasury, Primary Dealers and foreign central banks in the US market, in the Fed Report in the Professional Edition, Money Liquidity, and Real Estate Package. Try it risk free for 30 days. Get the research and analysis you need to understand these critical forces and stay ahead of the herd. Click this link and begin your risk free trial NOW!
- Claims Data Suggests Economy Overheating, and Fed Doesn’t Know It
- Housing Recovery Is An Illusion While Housing Inflation Rages
- Fix Was In In More Ways Than We Thought – Professional Edition
- Let US Start Each Day (Not just FOMC day) with The Pledge of Allegiance
- The Right Man For The Job! Meyer Lansky
- Strong Retail Sales Another Reason For Fed To Taper