Everything runs on liquidity. Unless you know something I don’t, that dollar bill in your pocket is just as likely to buy a can of Pabst Blue Ribbon today as it was yesterday, and will be tomorrow.
Liquidity moves markets!Follow the money. Find the profits!
Or you could sell 1,000 lbs. of gold – if you have that lying around – without fear of completely scuttling the global gold market. Your bank has to have cash, liquidity, lying around somewhere in the back if it wants to stay in business.
And in many cases, it’s easy to see or verify this liquidity. It helps everyone feel better about doing anything.
But there are markets where this liquidity is kept off the open exchanges, where it can be used to juice up huge deals. Or it can prevent these huge deals from having the impact that they “should” have, keeping the hands of large traders hidden.
These are the sinister-sounding dark pools of liquidity.
Dark liquidity is generated and stored in a variety of ways, most of which are possible due to the huge variety of trading venues, electronic and traditional.
With dark pools, neither the size of the order nor the entity making that order can be known until the order is completed. Rosenberg Securities Inc. estimates that fully 15% – trillions of dollars – of all trades occurring on American exchanges, every day, utilize dark pools.
Not Playing Straight Poker
And the markets, like nearly everything else, operate on the wide availability and transparency of good, reliable information. A poker game gets its lurid thrills from the partial presence of that information, or the possibility that the information could be faulty. You wouldn’t want to play with all your cards face-up. You just don’t know, and that’s why it’s fun to play poker.
But the markets, despite some inkling to the contrary, can’t function with true optimum efficiency if good information isn’t available to the widest possible group of participants.
It’s not that a player has to have the information, but it should be available to the player if things are going to work the way they should. One is a vying, gambling game, and the other is a free market. We should be able to tell the difference.
And there are nowadays big incentives and compelling reasons for large traders, for high-frequency traders, to maintain this half-plentiful supply of good information. Why? It’s simple. They’re making a killing off of arbitraging market inefficiency.
Billions of dollars are made, every day, from this activity, and none of it would be possible without dark pools. Entirely new companies, like Pipeline Trading Systems LLC, and Level ATS have popped up like mushrooms from dung to offer “private” counterparties for trades.
Some of these companies have already paid millions in fines, and they keep on keepin’ on. If that’s not an indication of the allure of dark liquidity, I don’t know what is.
There’s a New (Old) Sherriff In Town
The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) is the securities industry’s private self-regulator. It polices its own securities business, usually pretty well, and makes recommendations to the Securities and Exchange Commission for regulation. FINRA has the power to ban individuals and organizations from the industry for bad behavior.
FINRA has just approved a plan that would require dark pools to disclose – and even better – detail all the transactions that take place.
The ultimate aim isn’t just to illuminate the dark pools, but to make market manipulation more apparent to those who seek to quash it.
Just who FINRA and the SEC want to punish for market manipulation is something we’ve covered before, but most of their targets have received only minor penalties.
We may be faced with an environment in which dark pool trading is actively punished, but where the dark pool users gleefully fork over fines which amount to little skin.
This is part of a larger trend where regulators, in response to a growing outcry from retail investors, and in the face of another collapse caused by those who aren’t playing straight poker, attempt to crack down on various novel electronic trading tools.
As always, the regulators, the tail-end Charlies, will be hard-pressed to keep up with those who stand to gain tremendously from these methods.
- Wall Street Journal:
Finra Plan Would Shine Light on ‘Dark Pools’
Pipeline Settles With U.S. SEC Over Dark Pool Claims
Wall Street Examiner Disclosure: Lee Adler, The Wall Street Examiner reposts third party content with the permission of the publisher. The opinions expressed in these reposts are not those of the Wall Street Examiner or Lee Adler, unless authored by me, under my byline. I curate posts here on the basis of whether they represent an interesting and logical point of view, that may or may not agree with my own views. Some of the content includes the original publisher's promotional messages. No endorsement of such content is either expressed or implied by posting the content. All items published here are matters of information and opinion, and are neither intended as, nor should you construe it as, individual investment advice. Do your own due diligence when considering the offerings of information providers, or considering any investment.